James Milner and Danny Ings, positive signings for Liverpool FC?

Liverpool new boys; Milner left, Ings right

Today, Liverpool FC have confirmed the signing of Danny Ings on a free transfer, subject to compensation, a deal that follows another free transfer signing, James Milner. Both will join the club on July 1^st when the summer transfer window opens.

In a summer where Liverpool manager Brendan Rodgers has to get every signing absolutely right with no margin for error, it seems his first two deals are fairly safe ones. Milner, a steady performer, who brings a wealth of Premier League experience and Ings a pacey young player with potential in a position that needs improving most, up front.

There have already been wholesale changes to the backroom staff at the club as they look to change their fortunes following a rather drab season that petered out with two embarrassing defeats to Crystal Palace, Steven Gerrard’s Anfield fairwell, and Stoke. Rodgers’ two main right hand men Colin Pascoe and Mike Marsh are the first of many (should we believe the media) to be given the boot by the Liverpool hierarchy, but have remained faithful to Rodgers himself, however I feel this is a final warning. A poor start to next season could be curtains.

Another thing that is blindingly obvious is that Rodgers needs help in the transfer market with recruitment and negotiation. Last summer we paid premium prices for average players. £26m for Adam Lallana and £20m for Lazar Markovic among others when in the same transfer market Toni Kroos, one of the worlds most coveted midfielders who had just won the World Cup, was bought by Real Madrid for between £20-25m. Unbelievable. Liverpool need to follow models of clubs such as Atletico Madrid and Juventus who have spent a fraction of the money Liverpool who spent in recent years but have had far more success. Dejan Lovren, Lallana, Markovic and Mario Ballotelli were bought for around the same money it cost Juventus to assemble their starting 11 in the Champions League final on Saturday, £85m.  When you look as figures like this, it’s obvious where Liverpool are deficient. If other clubs in Europe had Liverpool’s wealth, they would be challenging on all fronts.

However, Milner and Ings do provide an improvement to the squad with little money spent which in my mind is positive.

James Milner

With Liverpool facing their first season post Gerrard, it is important to at least replace his experience and Premier League know how, as replacing his ability will be almost impossible. Milner provides this without commanding a fee, a safe option; he’s hardly an exciting signing or a player that will get you off your seat, but a good one. I’d much rather him in the team than Joe Allen or Lucas.

In his Man City career he was an underrated player (who wouldn’t be next to David Silva and Sergio Aguero) that grafted and did the leg work that allowed these players among others to shine.  A midfield with Milner in allowed players such as Yaya Toure and David Silva more of a free role to win matches, knowing that Milner would cover them. His work ethic for the team was to be admired but was never fully appreciated by certain fans. Many Man City fans would tell you how good he was, deceptively good technical ability and a turn of pace to beat a man, who was a useful cog in the Man City midfield. It comes as a surprise that they were willing for him to leave on a free considering he made 51 appearances in all competitions last season, often being preferred over Samir Nasri. This says something about his pedigree. Coaches seem to love him, dependable, reliable and consistent, you know what you’re getting with Milner which is why Rodgers went for him, he’s a fool proof signing, almost certain to do well which is exactly what Liverpool need. It says a lot about him that he’s willing to give up Champions League football for a starting position and regular football. He should fit nicely into Liverpool’s midfield alongside Jordan Henderson and Emre Can, a player I want to see in midfield next term.

Verdict: Good signing.

Danny Ings

Ings will arrive at Liverpool with less of a reputation than Milner, however still a useful acquisition. It’s no secret that Liverpool’s front line needs strengthening as Daniel Sturridge can’t seem to stay fit and the other forwards not cutting the mustard. Ings fits the bill. Young, pacey and a decent finisher, he has the ingredients to be a good player. He performed well in a struggling Burnley side last season that were very lacklustre in attack which wasn’t really Ings’ fault; they just lacked quality in all departments. He still managed 11 goals, more than all of Liverpool’s strikers last season combined, despite playing in a number 10 role, but I see him as a number 9.

He’s a player with good technical ability consisting of an excellent first touch and dribbling ability to beat defenders, a good strike but can sometimes be wayward with his passing. The one thing I liked about him most last season was the type of goals he scored; headers, tap ins, difficult and accurate finishes, in the right place at the right time, all this in a team that created very few opportunities for him.

My hopes are high for him. It will be interesting to see how he fits in with Sturridge, providing he’s fit, and Divock Origi another new signing. He may be deployed wide in his first season but hopefully he’s played in the number 9 role from time to time.

Verdict: Decent signing.

Both Milner and Ings are useful and needed signings but if they are the best players Liverpool buy this summer, they will look distinctly average ones. Liverpool still need big players, a world class striker if we can attract one, a new right back, goalkeeper, a winger to replace the want-away Raheem Sterling.

Liverpool just need to be a little more astute with their buys. There is plenty of talent available for reasonable money around Europe, something Rodgers has failed to get to grips with in his time at Liverpool, apart from Phillipe Coutinho and Sturridge who were bought relatively cheaply in January 2013.

I just hope there is more to come.

The pressure continues to build on Brendan Rodgers - but he's still the right man for the job

Despite yesterday’s victory over QPR, the pressure Brendan Rodgers is under has been growing for weeks and doesn't look like easing anytime soon. The discontent among the Anfield faithful, following a number of dismal performances, has led to some calling for his head in the knowledge that Jurgen Klopp and Rafael Benitez are available this summer. This led to the ‘Rodgers out Rafa in’ banner that was flown above Anfield during yesterday’s fixture. Whether the imbeciles were Liverpool fans or Man United fans having a joke remains to be seen, here’s hoping it was the latter attempting banter. Whoever it was, there’s no place for stunts like this in football.

The banner in question - allegedly made by Liverpool fans

Not long ago I wrote about the 5 reasons I thought Rodgers was still the right man for the job, and I still fully stand by this. He’s had a tough season, but he’s had more to deal with this year than any other of his career, with one thing after another seemingly going wrong.

Firstly, he originally had to deal with the extra pressure of the Champions League, this being his first season managing in the competition and arguably managing a team not equipped to deal with the rigorous midweek to weekend fixture schedule. This was the case as it turned out. Perhaps it was a season too soon, as silly as it sounds; I don’t think the team were ready for the enormous step up in quality. Having said that, Liverpool couldn't have drawn a better group; a clash with the Champions, the worst second seed team and unheard of minnows. Not qualifying from that group was massively disappointing.

Additionally Steven Gerrard’s decline has been a huge issue for the club and Rodgers struggled to deal with him in a respectful manner. Clearly he’s not good enough to play every week anymore but many, including myself, feel Rodgers could have dealt with the situation much better. It was just unfortunate for him that Gerrard is a club legend, a huge personality, something that Rodgers hasn’t encountered before in how to tell Gerrard in a dignified way that he’s not needed anymore. He will learn from this, but a blot on his copybook.

Raheem Sterling’s public contact issues have also been no favour to Rodgers, an extra distraction away from trying to improve the team. A team weakened by the summer departure of Luis Suarez, a player that almost single handily mounted Liverpool’s title challenge last season. Dealing with his loss was always going to be a massive task for any manager, unfortunately the summer signings haven’t come close to replacing his goals.

Suarez celebrating one of his many goals last season

Daniel Sturridge, a man who Rodgers would have pinpointed as the top striker at the club and the man to fill Suarez’s boots, has been ravaged with injury this season missing the majority of matches. Yet another massive dilemma that Rodgers has had to find a solution for, and with Fabio Borini, Rickie Lambert and Mario Balotelli as alternatives, it never looked solvable. This can be attributed to poor transfer business, considering all three are his signings.

However, despite all these problems and predicaments, Liverpool lie only four points behind Man United, who are fourth in the league, with three games to play which gives them an outside chance of Champions League qualification. However unlikely this may seem, considering everything that has happened this season and how poor Liverpool have been at times, it’s a respectable position to be in.

Therefore I still believe Rodgers should be given next season to turn it around and let his summer signings have another season under his management. After all, I am convinced those that have flattered to deceive such as Lazar Markovic and Dejan Lovren will turn it around and have a far better 2015/16.

One final point I will make is that there is no doubt in my mind that Rodgers needs help in the transfer market. His record since joining the club has been extremely poor in terms of how many bad players he’s bought. I’m not a fan of the Director of Football position that most clubs adopt, but I think with Brendan, it would be a massive help for him. However it should be considered with caution as Liverpool could easily hire someone equally inept in the transfer market who would deliver yet more disappointing signings. FSG surely have to be running out of patience, Rodgers needs a positive summer window this time around.

Whatever happens in terms of management, I will support whoever is at the helm whether it is Rodgers, Klopp or Benitez – all three I’m sure can do a great job at the club.

5 reasons Brendan Rodgers is still the right man for the Liverpool Job

As we build up to tonight’s FA Cup replay against Blackburn Rovers, there has been more and more naïve Liverpool fans calling for Brendan Rodgers’ head should we lose the game, following our last two results. The same fans that were praising him for our turnaround little more than a month ago, such is the modern fickle fan. This in my opinion is absurd. For me, even if we lose tonight’s match at Ewood Park he is still the right man to take the club forward, and here are 5 reasons why.

1)      Last season’s success

Granted, we didn’t win a trophy or win the league but had you offered most fans second place at the start of the season, they would’ve bitten your hand off. Even if the end of the season was a bit of an anti-climax, the sumptuous style of play Rodgers had created was fantastic to watch and scoring over 100 league goals was testament to that. Unfortunately we haven’t reached those heights this season, however it took two seasons to mount a serious title challenge and having bought a near whole new team last summer following the departure of Luis Suarez, it was always going to take time for everyone to gel. Next season has the potential to be as spectacular as Brendan’s second year in charge, providing he buys well in the summer and keeps our best players.

2)      Development of players

Rodgers has proved in nearly three years at the club that he is a fantastic coach, having developed the likes of Raheem Sterling, Phillipe Coutinho and Daniel Strurridge. All these players of course had undoubted talent but under the tuition of Rodgers have kicked on to the next level, or in Sterling’s case, many levels. He has also developed a player who was heavily criticised in the early stages of his Liverpool career, Jordan Henderson, into a player who is being talked about as the heir to Gerrard’s Anfield throne. Other players such as Martin Skrtel, John Flanagan and Mamadou Sakho also deserve a mention as they have also developed massively since Rodgers taking charge, or since buying them.  If he can sustain the number of players developing and continue to do so, there is no doubt he is the right man for the job.

3)      Trust in Youth

One of the main things that has impressed me about Rodgers since taking over The Reds is the level of trust he places in youth players. Liverpool are a club well known for their youth academy over the years having produced the likes of Michael Owen, Steven Gerrard, Jamie Carragher and Robbie Fowler. However, since the likes of Gerrard and Owen, there hadn’t been a really successful academy graduate until Sterling (if he counts) and since then, Flanagan and Jordon Ibe. Of course Flanagan and Ibe haven’t achieved anything yet but the potential is there. So it’s nice to see a young manager trusting young players, so much so that youngster Jordan Williams has been on the bench for many games this season. What particularly encourages me for the future is decisions like he made with Ibe, a young player playing well on loan in a position we needed depth in, so instead of buying, Rodgers recalled Ibe which has been fully justified having excelled in most games he’s played since returning.  The rate of academy graduates appearing in the first team has without doubt increased since Rodgers took over and is another reason I think he should stay.

4)      He’s tactically astute

Now, I’m going to be the first to admit that Rodgers has made tactical errors in the past, as I’m sure he would admit himself, but on the whole he’s excelled. Particularly during the tail end of last season where game by game he would create a plan and tweak the system appropriate for our opponents, using a combination of different formations and styles. This season as well, he managed to turn around a frankly disastrous start to the season where the team couldn’t defend into a solid unit and renewed aspirations for Champions League football. Obviously this is looking distant now but the fact he turned it round to go unbeaten for 3 months is testament to his tactical acumen and coaching. I fully believe he will only improve in this area as he’s obviously a fast learner, and his decisions in the big games will become better. He is, in my opinion, one of the best man managers in the country and is extremely bright which is why he should without doubt keep his job.

5)      Still young and learning

On top of all that’s been said, he’s still young for a manager at 42 and is still learning his trade. Every manager makes mistakes, Sir Alex Ferguson didn’t win anything for the first six years of his reign at Man United. Jose Mourinho has often got it wrong and it’s well documented that Arsene Wenger has got it wrong on many occasions. That being said, for a young manager he has done remarkably well in his first big job, no disrespect to Swansea or the other clubs he’s managed. Dealing with the added pressure with calmness and dignity, I believe he will become a world class manager and Liverpool would be foolish to get rid of him, contrary to some of the idiots that think otherwise.

Liverpool's new system paying dividends

The new formation that's proven a success

After yesterday’s fantastic 2-0 win against Southampton, it was highlighted by Brendan Rodgers in his post-match interview that Coutinho’s wonderful opener was down to the system before acknowledging the individual brilliance.

‘It was a wonderful goal, I think in terms of the system and how we play it was a great demonstration of that… moving the ball out onto the sides, draws the team across and then allows the central players the space’ Rodgers said to the BBC before explaining that it was actually a phenomenal piece of skill.

I think crediting a goal of that type to the system is a little farfetched. Players get space in the middle a number of times in a game, it’s just wasted in most cases or just passed wide.

But ‘Brodgers’, as Noel Gallagher called Brendan on Match of the Day 2, does have a point when talking about the new system and its effectiveness, although I think the focus should be at the other end of the pitch, the improved defence.

There is no doubt that after last season’s sensational campaign, where Liverpool finished second in the league only 2 points behind the eventual winners Man City, that the defence had to be improved. ‘The Brodge’ went to work in the summer transfer market signing three new defenders to patch up the leaky defence. Moreno, Lovren and Manquillo were brought in for a lot of money (Manquillo on loan) as a solution.

In the early parts of the season the signings seemed futile. Goals continued to be shipped in at the wrong end, in fact the defence had got worse with the addition of the new signings. However I wouldn’t attribute the problems entirely on the new boys. Mignolet, Skrtel and Glen Johnson were particularly error prone and performing well below par, attracting much criticism.

Something had to be done with the club languishing in the lower depths of the top half.

It was Sunday 14th of December, Man United away. One of the biggest fixtures in the domestic calendar. Things looked bleak following elimination from the Champions League at home in a dismal 1-1 draw with Basel the previous Tuesday. A change was needed. Pressure was most certainly on Rodgers in the toughest period of his fledgling managerial career. How would he respond? A change of formation.

It came as a surprise to the media and fans alike when Liverpool changed formation and went with a 3-4-2-1 with wingbacks. Especially in light of the defensive problems that had troubled the club. The decision to play no recognised striker was also a shock, instead deploying Raheem Sterling through the middle with Lallana and Coutinho in close proximity. It offered far more movement in the final third in place of the labouring Balotelli, who at the time still hadn’t scored his first Premier League goal.

To sum up, Liverpool lost 3-0, a score line that flattered Man United in a game where Liverpool had the better chances but met an inspired Man United goalkeeper in David de Gea, who saved everything that came in his direction.

Despite the result, the performance was much improved. Far more movement and energy in the final third, far more pressure put on the opponent in possession, a feature of the Liverpool side of last season that hounded opposition into submission before killing them off with deadly finishing. The trio of Sterling, Lallana and Coutinho looked to bear fruit with bright performances, despite their missed chances.

It turned out to be a stepping stone and a platform to improve from having only lost one game (the away leg in the capital one cup semi-final against Chelsea after extra time) since the defeat. Rodgers persisted with the three at the back and has brought in Emre Can and Mamadou Sakho since to flank Martin Skrtel. The three have since formed a solid basis and are a fundamental reason for the incredible turn around and form of late.

It’s a formation that complements the players Liverpool have at this current time. Obviously Can isn’t a centre back by trade, but he’s excelled in the position and for such a young man, the future looks bright. Skrtel and Sakho look far more comfortable as part of a back three with the extra man next to them. Alberto Moreno looks far better with slightly less defensive responsibility and more license to get forward, something that was catching him out when part of a back four. Lazar Markovic has performed better as a wingback than a winger and the addition of Lucas to midfield has been crucial, someone to break up the play. Gerrard is being used far more sporadically which seems to have benefitted the team as there’s less of a reliance on the talismanic captain, and players like Henderson and Coutinho have stepped up to the plate.

The positioning of the defence has also been much improved. A more solid structure as part of a back three with more help from midfield and a more mobile attack has contributed to the defensive enhancement. I must not forget to mention Simon Mignolet and his return to form has been a definitive factor, and also Jordon Ibe coming into the side and performing extraordinarily. Even Balotelli looks to have upped his game despite Rodgers’ recent outburst criticising his work rate. The fact that Daniel Sturridge hasn’t had to be rushed back like many thought he would is testament to the new system and the incredible turn around that Rodgers has martialled. He is no doubt going to be a huge player between now and the end of the season.

Testament to Rodgers, he’s improved the side defensively, with five clean sheets in a row away from home in the League. Credit where credit’s due. Experimenting with a formation that’s been tried and often criticised by many, such as when Man United use it, Louis Van Gaal has been lambasted by the media and fans.

Obviously its early days of the revival, and nothing has been achieved yet, but if form continues as it has been, then top four is a realistic ambition which was unfathomable late last year. Rodgers has passed his latest test and continues to go from strength to strength, no doubt highlighted by the win at Southampton yesterday, a game if played in October, would more than likely have ended in defeat.

I’m going to stop sucking up to Rodgers now. Let’s just say he’s done a great job and leave it at that. The new system is most certainly paying dividends.

Let me know if you agree!